Comments on: Federal government attempts to deny Chelsea Manning entry into Australia /news/national-news/federal-government-attempts-deny-chelsea-manning-entry-australia/171450 Setting Australia’s LGBTI agenda since 1979 Fri, 31 Aug 2018 06:59:22 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.7.1 By: Dave /news/national-news/federal-government-attempts-deny-chelsea-manning-entry-australia/171450#comment-604081 Fri, 31 Aug 2018 06:59:22 +0000 https://starobserver.com.au/?p=171450#comment-604081 In reply to Michael tiyce.

You are correct, but so what? She served seven years which is a lot, and this sentence was deemed appropriate by the highest official in the land at the time the sentence was commuted. There are plenty of people with criminal convictions allowed to enter Australia, particularly in cases where there is zero risk of them continuing to offend (she doesn’t have access to classified files, ergo she can’t leak them).

The law under which she was convicted gives no opportunity to argue the grounds of whistleblowing or public interest. It’s a flawed law. If you’re convicted by crap laws that says more about the lawmakers than you. Just ask anyone convicted of gay sex a generation ago.

Morality is far more a judge of character than legality. Chelsea exposed illegal conduct in an immoral war, to the embarrassment of the Bush administration. Not legally defensible but certainly morally defensible.

]]>
By: Nikola Kovacs /news/national-news/federal-government-attempts-deny-chelsea-manning-entry-australia/171450#comment-604080 Fri, 31 Aug 2018 02:51:10 +0000 https://starobserver.com.au/?p=171450#comment-604080 In reply to Michael tiyce.

Are you saying she did the wrong thing by exposing that teh Americans were killing innocent civilians?

]]>
By: Michael tiyce /news/national-news/federal-government-attempts-deny-chelsea-manning-entry-australia/171450#comment-604076 Thu, 30 Aug 2018 06:50:32 +0000 https://starobserver.com.au/?p=171450#comment-604076 As repulsive as southern and milo are they aren’t criminals with espionage convictions. there is a big difference between them and Chelsea. Chelseas sentence was commuted, she was not pardoned.

]]>